Tuesday, November 17, 2026

 November 17th, 2026


Politics - Zelenskyy clarifies on NATO - Donbas issue

- Kerch Bridge span dropped

- Starshield still down


Combat Ops - Strikes continue

- Ground actions very slow


Weather


Wet and colder; this will further degrade ground combat operations on both sides, but will also impede ISR drones, which means it will be harder to spot ground elements as they move.


Kharkiv

36 and cloudy, gusting to 20. Rain tonight and on and off through Friday night, snow next week. Daily lows in the 40s through Saturday, daily highs in the upper 40s, but in the 30s next week. Winds variable, 10-15kts.


Melitopol

49 and rain, gusting over 20. Rain showers through the day Friday, then again starting Sunday afternoon. Daily lows in the 40s, daily highs in the 50s. Winds variable, 10-15kts.


Kyiv

42 and cloudy. Rain starts tonight continues through early Thursday morning, then more rain Friday during the day. Daily lows in the 40s, daily highs in the 50s. Winds variable, 5-10kts.



Politics


Yesterday I reported that President Zelenskyy would consider asking the Ukrainian people if they would consider a de facto ceding of the Donbas to Russia in exchange for NATO membership. Since then more commentary has made it clear that Zelenskyy doesn’t see it as that clear cut:

"We cannot turn everything upside down and start by talking about changing the security framework in the world or across the continent overall, and only then talk about ending this war. This war must be ended first.”


Aide to President Putin Yuri Ushakov commented yesterday on European participation in the peace talks:

"This was not agreed with us.”


1 span of the Kerch bridge has collapsed.


Ukrainian officials continue to report limits to Starshield operations over Ukraine. SpaceX, which owns Starshield, continues to insist that it is a technical issue 


  PM Magyar has announced that rail service to Ukraine is being halted for today and tomorrow following a Russian drone striking near the train station in Mukachevo, Zakarpattia oblast.  A train had just arrived from Hungary (the border is 20 miles away) and the Hungarian crew was evacuated from the train following the strike.

The train was not damaged and there were no wounded.



Air and Maritime Operations


Ukrainian Forces


Open source imagery showed at least three scorch marks on the Kerch Bridge, suggesting three separate drone or missile strikes, before the main span collapsed earlier today.


Ukrainian forces continue strikes on Russian oil and transportation infrastructure, hitting the oil refinery in Salavat, about 700 miles east of Moscow.


Russian Forces


During the period of November 16th-November 17th Russian forces launched an undisclosed number of Iskander and S-400 ballistic missiles, KH-59/60 cruise missiles,  and 306 x strike drones into Ukrainian airspace. The UAF claimed it shot down or defeated 3 cruise missiles, 3 loitering munitions, and 205 drones 

Damage was reported in Cherkasy, Chernihiv, Dnipropetrovsk, Donetsk, Kharkiv, Khmelnitskyi, Kyiv,  Mykolaiv, Poltava, Rivne, Sumy, Ternopil, Vinnytsia, and Zaporizhzhia oblasts. 

Ballistic missiles struck Cherkasy, Dnipropetrovsk, Kharkiv, Kyiv, and Zaporizhzhia. Both the north and south bridges in Kyiv have been hit as well as the Preobrazhenskyi Bridge in Zaporizhzhia City yesterday afternoon.

Power outages were reported in Dnipropetrovsk, and Rivne and Zaporizhzhia oblasts. Zaporizhzhia was also struck with glide bombs.

Civilian casualties include at least 9 killed and 33 wounded.


A drone - origin unknown - struck m/v GAS HUSKY (LPG tanker, Liberian flag, 392 feet, 7,200 DWT) 50 miles east of Byala, Bulgaria and the ship has sunk. A life raft was spotted near the site of the sinking and Bulgarian naval and air forces are working to recover all crew members.



Ground Operations


Multiple infiltration by Russian troops were noted the length of the front, and there appears to have been some minor adjustments of lines, but there were no confirmed changes in who holds what terrain.

With the arrival of colder weather, as well as some rain, and the loss of the remaining foliage cover, movement will be more difficult for the next 4 to 6 weeks until the ground freezes and allows more off-road movement; changes on the ground will, in all likelihood, be fewer and slower.



Economic Reporting


         Feb22  Aug7 Sep8 Oct8 Nov10 Nov16 Nov17

Brent      94.71   81.75 98.19 105.80 89.80 93.18 93.40

WTI     92.10   76.66 93.28 92.99 84.69 86.58 86.69

NG       3.97        2.64 2.95   3.16   3.23 3.14 3.11

Wheat     8.52           6.35   7.46 6.86   5.88 5.89 6.12

Ruble     85        82.61 86.21 85.20 82.99 82.35 81.99

Hryvnia 28.6 44.73 44.63 44.93 45.36 45.34 45.20

Urals 91.66 79.19 89.44 123.93 72.96 71.39 71.10

ESPO 94.52 78.79 98.44 108.70 118.57 125.84 122.44

Sokol 99.31 77.42 94.09 109.20 99.38 102.82 99.21


ESPO Forward, 17 November - 114.03



Thoughts


President Zelenskyy’s clarification that he would discuss the idea of NATO membership in exchange for de facto Russian control of the Donbas only after the war is ended strikes me as convoluted at best. NATO membership is the thing that Kyiv has been saying it wants, and now it has been offered and his response is that the war needs to end first, which, given the current environment, seems quite unlikely.

Meanwhile, Ukrainian forces have dropped the Kerch bridge, after multiple attempts since the start of the war. It’s probably a pretty good bet that the Russians will now try to drop many bridges, not simply the ones in Kyiv and Zaporizhzhia city, but along the rest of the Dnepr River and several other sites. The loss of the Kerch bridge will be very unpleasant to Crimea, but the bridge has only been opened since 2019 - Crimea has survived without that bridge. The loss of multiple bridges across the Dnepr would markedly complicate logistics support to Ukraine’s front line forces and would present a serious problem for the city of Kyiv.

Said differently, we are probably now further from a peace treaty AND the war just escalated.


v/r pete


Monday, November 16, 2026

 

November 16th, 2026


Politics - Zelenskyy comments on US idea (Ukraine in NATO)

- Putin says “no NATO troops”

- Kerch Bridge damaged but open

- Starshield problems continue


Combat Ops - Strikes continue

- Ground sees little change


Weather


Wet and colder; this will further degrade ground combat operations on both sides, but will also impede ISR drones, which means it will be harder to spot ground elements as they move.


Kharkiv

37 and sunny. Rain starts tomorrow afternoon and continues through Friday night.  Tomorrow will start cold - in the upper 20s, then, warming with daily lows in the 40s and daily highs near 50. Winds south-easterly, 10-15kts.


Melitopol

40 and partly cloudy. Rain starts tomorrow afternoon, continues through Friday during the day. Daily lows in the 30s tomorrow then in the 40s, daily highs in the 50s. Winds variable, 10-15kts.


Kyiv

43 and cloudy. Rain starts tonight continues through early Thursday morning, then more rain Friday during the day. Low tomorrow mid 30s, rest of week daily low in the 40s, daily highs near 50. Winds variable, 10-15kts.



Politics


President Zelenskyy commented on a proposed US plan to end the war:

“The Americans raised the question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this issue had been raised.”

Donbas is the combined region of Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts.

“If the American side confirms precisely this to us, together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks: Do we accept it or not?”

As to Russian calls for Ukrainian neutrality as part of any peace process, Zelenskyy commented:

“If Putin expects Ukraine’s neutrality to be enshrined, that’s not going to happen. We’re not in NATO right now anyway.” He suggested that Putin “desire[s] to change borders in Europe. This is dangerous because, in my view, it is precisely things like this that lead to wars or escalations….The sequence should be as follows: a ceasefire, an end to the war in Ukraine, and security guarantees for Ukraine. There can be no security guarantees in Europe, or for Europe, without Ukraine.”


For his part President Putin again stated that any European or NATO troops in Ukraine after a ceasefire would be viewed as a direct threat to Moscow and end the ceasefire:

“In other words, the war would resume immediately.”


Ukrainian forces struck the Kerch bridge and the bridge was closed for several hours. Imagery shows burn marks at several points and one image appears to show that one arch of the bridge has been knock off true vertical. But the Bridge has apparently been reopened to limited traffic.


Ukrainian officials continue to report speed limitations on the use of Starshield communications paths to their drones.

Starshield continues to insist that there are no restriction in place but has suggested that there are some technical issues that are causing problems.


Estonia announced it will close its border with Russia on December 1st after a recent arson attack against an Estonian drone manufacturer after which Estonian officials arrested 8 men - all Latvian - but the Estonian government has asserted that the men were working for Russian military intelligence (GRU).

There was no significant damage to the manufacturing facility.


A number of commercial aircraft over the Netherlands had a loss of GPS signals in the vicinity of Texel island, about 50 miles north of Amsterdam and on the approach to Schiphol airport (the airport for Amsterdam).

At the time there were three Russian owned, sanctioned tankers underway near the island. 

Seven aircraft reported interference.



Air and Maritime Operations


Ukrainian Forces


Ukrainian forces continue strikes on Russian oil and transportation infrastructure.


During the night of November 15th-November 16th Ukrainian forces struck the Kerch bridge (see above).


During the night of November 14th-November 15th Ukrainian forces struck the Nizhnekamskneftekhim petrochemical complex, about 500 miles east of Moscow.


During the night of November 13th-November 14th Ukrainian forces struck fuel and repair facilitates at Lipetsk air base.


During the night of November 12th-November 13th Ukrainian forces struck a drone production facilities in the Rostov-on-Don area.


Russian Forces


Over the course of the last 3 nights Russian forces have launched at least 478 strike drones and the UAF has claimed to have shot down 274. As a reminder, the UAF is no longer providing detailed reporting on missiles or drones or engagements, so these numbers are going to be both low and will fill in over time as data filters out.

Civilian casualties included at leasts 11 killed and 95 wounded.

Nearly every oblast reported some damage, and power outages were reported in Cherkasy, Dnipropetrovsk, Kharkiv, Kirovohrad, Odesa, Poltava, Ternopil, and Vinnytsia oblasts

Glide bombs again struck targets in Zaporizhzhia, and other cities closer to the front lines. Drone strikes also continue against bridges over the Dnipr in Kyiv and in Zaporizhzhia.


Of note, Russian strikes on Ukraine’s rail system has now destroyed more than 630 locomotives, about 1/4th of the operational total (as of 2022), and 63% of Ukraine’s rolling stock.


Four ships were struck off Romania (In Romanian waters) between Friday and Sunday in the vicinity of Sulina, Romania (just south of the border with Ukraine).

Evia Petrol V (oil products tanker, Greek Flag, 390 feet, 7,000 DWT)

Ali Najatov (general cargo, Nevis and St Kitts flag, 371 feet, 6,600 DWT )

Marsol (general cargo, Nevis and St Kitts flag, 485 feet, 18,000 DWT)

Larissa 1 (general cargo, Palau flag, 380 feet, 17,000 tons)

These four ships have since gotten underway and are on their own power.


Off Bulgaria BETUL 8 (general cargo, Somali flag, 243 feet, 3200 DWT, carrying wheat from Romania to Egypt) was reportedly struck, capsized and sank. Bulgarian Naval, Air and Coast Guard personnel have rescued all 18 crew.


Technology and Tactics


Russian forces have begun using a ground-launched variant of the Dan-T loitering munition, apparently with the aim being to reduce alert time for Ukrainian air defense forces.



Ground Operations


Infiltrations continue by both sides and there have been small gains made at several points along the line by both sides.

Imagery confirmed small Ukrainian gains north-east of Kharkiv.

Ukrainian reports note that Russian forces have advanced in the area of Zarichne (east of Lyman), pushing Ukrainian forces a bit further west from the Zherebets River. 

Just to the south, Russian forces made modest gains east of Slovyansk.

Russian forces continue to consolidate their holdings in Kostiantinivka but reporting also shows that Ukrainian forces continue to hold their positions in the city, reinforcing the “checkerboard” nature of the disposition of forces. 

Ukrainian reporting notes, however, that Russian forces continue to slowly build up in the Kostiantinivka to Dobripillia area, to include moving of more mechanized elements into the area.

In the center Ukrainian forces made some gains along the north bank of the Vovcha River, and Russian forces have probably withdrawn to the Dachne area.

And just south of this, Ukrainian forces have pushed across the Mokri Yaly River, east of the town of Vesele. Ukrainian forces have not reached the prepared Russian defensive lines, but they have crossed the River. They now need to hold that ground. Russian forces will obviously try to cut their supply lines and push them back across the river. The next few months of cold and wet weather, and muddy terrain, will make this difficult for both sides.



Economic Reporting


         Feb22  Aug7 Sep8 Oct8 Nov10 Nov13 Nov16

Brent      94.71   81.75 98.19 105.80 89.80 96.30 93.18

WTI     92.10   76.66 93.28 92.99 84.69 88.97 86.58

NG       3.97        2.64  2.95   3.16   3.23 3.27 3.14

Wheat     8.52            6.35   7.46 6.86           5.88 5.95 5.89

Ruble     85        82.61 86.21 85.20 82.99 82.59 82.35

Hryvnia 28.6 44.73 44.63 44.93 45.36 45.37 45.34

Urals 91.66 79.19 89.44 123.93 72.96 71.39 71.39

ESPO 94.52 78.79 98.44 108.70 118.57 N/A 125.84

Sokol 99.31 77.42 94.09 109.20 99.38 103.04 102.82


ESPO Forward, 16 November - N/A



Thoughts


This is the first hint that Zelenskyy has given that he might cede (de facto, not de jury) Ukrainian terrain. So, maybe a faint glimmer. 

But it seems a reach that Putin will readily sign up to an agreement that has NATO troops in Ukraine. Perhaps if it is called something else. Still, who will do it? There are no European forces that could sustain any sort of reasonable force in central Ukraine - except the US.

And any force will need air defense, early warning, intelligence, command and control, and logistics support that will only come from the US. 

Still, a faint reason for hope, perhaps. (Not that hope is a plan.)


v/r pete