Thursday, June 28, 2012

TaxCare

MDs work on taxes and CPAs work on healthcare.  It must be true.  Chief Justice Roberts says so.

The Chief Justice wrote, in the opinion that supported the ObamaCare legislation, that:

"That Clause [the commerce clause] authorizes Congress to regulate interstate commerce, not to order individuals to engage it. In this case, however, it is reasonable to construe what Congress has done as increasing taxes on those who have a certain amount of income, but choose to go without health insurance. Such legislation is within Congress's power to tax."

Never mind that no one is writing or voting for this legislation thought they were drafting a part of the tax code.  Apparently the intent of the drafters was of zero consequence to the Chief Justice.

Now, those with the income to choose can either pay a tax penalty or purchase a healthcare plan.  It’s an ‘either – or’ tax: either buy (or do) what we want or pay a penalty.  Well, I must admit that that is brilliant: we know that the government has used taxes to alter (or try to alter) behavior: raise taxes on cigarettes to try and force people to smoke less, for example.   There are those who object to such actions, but the Supreme Court has now signaled that that is legitimate legislation: Congress is free to pass legislation to use penalties (now called taxes) to force behavior on those who can’t afford the penalty.

Where does this lead?  Well, first, it means the government can force the citizenry to buy things the government feels we should be buying: “Buy a Chevy Volt or pay a tax.”  But, more to the point, it can, through ever-higher taxes, simply force certain behavior on “those who have a certain amount of income” by slowly ratcheting up the “tax” on non-compliance.  “Buy a Chevy Volt or pay a tax” eventually becomes “Buy a Chevy Volt or pay a $100,000 tax.”

Secondly, beginning in 2015 (one year into the full enactment of the law) the “tax” penalty will start to climb, forcing more and more businesses to buy the healthcare insurance.  What will follow?  The insurance costs will increase, as will healthcare costs, as more and more government mandated funds become available for the healthcare industry, with rapidly decreasing market forces to keep costs in check.  (Don’t think so?  Look what happened to medical costs since Medicare, or education costs since the creation of the Department of Education.)  True private healthcare will be a thing of the past by the mid 2020s, and healthcare costs will soar, as there will be no reason to hold costs in check.  (Eventually, this will cause a reflex response by the same government, resulting in the very close, very real rationing of healthcare by the same accountants and bureaucrats.)

Third, the government, in the form of the bureaucracies that make up the executive branch, is now free to use the “power to tax” to force virtually any form of behavior modification on anyone, all in the name of taxation.  Want those pesky citizens to do something?  Easy, “tax” them for non-compliance.  Solar panels on houses or pay a penalty, drink fewer sodas or pay a penalty, get your body mass index below a certain number of pay a penalty, have fewer than four children or pay a penalty.  Hey, come-on, it’s just a tax and that’s ok, Chief Justice Roberts said so.

Truly, the power to tax is the power to destroy.

I’m headed to my accountant for my back pain.


Monday, June 18, 2012

Immigration Reform

I had an interesting e-mail exchange with a friend the other day, the gist of it being that the people we know who are of Mexican descent are overwhelmingly ferociously American.  They love their country, and they, like the millions of other immigrants of various origins – Ireland, England, Germany, China, Japan, Korea, West Africa, North Africa, Italy, the Middle East, India, Spain, the Philippines, etc. – are committed and loyal and hardworking Americans.

Overwhelmingly, they arrived in the US legally.  At the same time, they all have relatives or friends, equally hard-working, equally committed and loyal to the US, who did Not arrive here legally.  Many have been here for decades, but are nonetheless here illegally.

And so it leads to this ‘simple’ question: what is the appropriate solution?

Should we grant amnesty?  Or should we force out all who are here illegally?  The US is, after all, a nation of laws, not men.  And it must remain so.  Is that the final answer?  Is there no gray area?  Should there be no gray area, no possible compromise?  Is the letter of the law the final answer?  Or is there another piece to the puzzle?  Should compassion play a role?  And should US interests play a role?  And if there is some gray area, how can we deal fairly with those who are following the law in trying to become US citizens?

The President has recently weighed in with a plan that will allow an estimated 800,000 folks here illegally, to remain in the US if they continue their education, or serve in the military, have no criminal records, etc.  It is an interesting proposal.  But there are two things wrong with it.

The first is simply this: It’s against the law.  Senator Rubio, the junior senator from Florida, suggested just such a proposal a short while ago and it did not successfully make its way to law.  His proposal would change the law and allow those here illegally, if they satisfy certain criteria, to remain in the US, and to apply for citizenship.  Current US law does not allow that.  Hence, the law needs to be changed, if this it to be the manner in which the US handles certain illegal aliens.

President Obama, apparently not being terribly concerned with the niceties of the Constitution in which the Legislature enacts laws – and changes them, has decided to change the law himself.  That is interesting behavior for a Constitutional Law professor.  But, that is what he has done.

The second problem with this new course of action is simply this: there is no cost to those who have broken the law.  In effect, people are being rewarded for illegal behavior.  Am I looking for Draconian responses?  Certainly not.  But there is merit to the notion that, as Thomas Paine put it: “That which we obtain too cheaply we esteem to lightly.”  In short, there ought to be some penalty.  That penalty can be (and should be) simply monetary – a one time fee.  But it is necessary that a philosophical point be made: you must pay for breaking the law.

All this, of course, doesn’t answer what we should do about illegal immigration.  My own response to this all is, I think, horribly selfish.  By that I mean, I think the answer should involve at its core the idea of doing what is best for the United States and if others don’t like it, well – too bad.

The important question then is simply this: what is best for the US?  I would suggest that isn’t, despite all the noise on the news, really that difficult a thing to determine.  First, obviously, this is about those people, from whatever country, who are in the US illegally.  If they have a Green Card, if they have asked for sanctuary, if they are working through the process for citizenry, then this concept doesn’t concern them directly – except that in the latter case we do need to resolve the issue of fair treatment.  But the central issue is that of people who are in the US illegally.  And the US response should be to address US interests first.  And what are US interests?

I would answer that in this regard the nation’s interests are: Security, the Economy, and the Integrity of the nation.  As far as security goes, the US should be concerned that it can control its borders and its territory.  Procedures should be put in place to prevent people from illegally entering this country and from illegally living in and operating from this country.  We can debate what those might be, but we need to start with the simple concept that a nation needs to control its borders; there needs to be real control.  Secondly, security should involve ensuring that the nation is safe and in this case that means that those who are in the US illegally AND are engaging in criminal activity or activity that damages the US, US interests or the US economy should be either incarcerated (if they have committed a capital offense and are convicted of it), or quickly kicked out of the country, and are ineligible for return.

Economy: simply put, those who are contributing to our economy should be considered separately from those who do not. If you are employed, but here illegally, you might be required to immediately begin work on citizenship, and then pay a penalty, in the form of a sliding scale affixed to their income tax for a period of perhaps 3 years: the more they earn and the longer they have been here, the more they pay.  It doesn’t need to be an onerous, confiscatory tax, just one that recoups some government cost, perhaps a 5% to 15% increase on their taxes.  Those who are in the US illegally, are 18 years old or older, are unemployed, and are ineligible for a student visa, would be sent home.  If they are eligible for a student visa, they can apply for one, and they will be taxed – a penalty.  Pay the penalty (again, within a given timeframe) and qualify for the visa and they stay.  Otherwise, they leave.  As for military service as an avenue for citizenship, that actually has been on the books for quite a while.  Expanding it to allow someone who is in the US illegally to join up, assuming he meets all other requirements – and is willing to swear loyalty to the US – is really not that new a concept.

There is an objection to this position, that being that the illegal immigrants are taking jobs away from US citizens.  This “solution” really is reduced to two issues: penalizing the worker (the illegal immigrant), as discussed above, and penalizing the employer.  If the employer knowingly hired an illegal worker, simply stripping him of his worker(s) may satisfy some thirst for retribution, but hardly serves our combined interests for a healthy economy in the form of productive and profitable businesses.  Again, I think the best answer (and I recognize it is not perfect and will upset others), is to penalize the employer – a set fee per worker is probably the best answer, and then ensure that standard workplace rules are being followed: taxes, insurance, etc., etc.  The penalty would need to be large enough to be at least to some degree ‘painful,’ but it shouldn’t actually cause a drop in productivity – we are trying to grow the economy, not kill it with the death of a thousand cuts.  (Of course, once identified everyone needs to follow the law, as well as apply for US citizenship.)  Accordingly, the employer penalty needs to be carefully chosen, but again, should not be onerous.  (One that resulted in the employer firing some workers therefore is clearly counter-productive.)

How would we construct such a process without seeming to benefit the illegal immigrant at the expense of the unemployed citizen?  That is more difficult.  Penalties may have been paid, but we are still left with US citizens without employment.  The unpleasant truth however, is that there are no meaningful statistics that show that long-term unemployment rolls are materially affected by immigration – legal or illegal.  A healthy US economy would generate in excess of 2.5 million new jobs every year.  That is has not is a failure of the administration’s economic policies, not a result of immigration, or immigration policies.  Lashing the two together makes for good headlines, but fails to accurately address the real economic issues that are causing the unemployment and under-employment problem in the US.

Returning to the issue of immigration, I would add that for those immigrants who have something extra to offer: a patent of some value; an MD or some other list of desirable professionals, you should move up the list for entry and citizenship.  Is that, strictly speaking, fair?  Probably not.  Then again, I’m not trying to be fair.  I want to look out for US interests.  If you are smart or rich or talented I think it should be easier for you to become a citizen then your poor, dumb, untalented brother.  Look on it as picking a team: I think we should pick the best team we can.

For children who are in the US illegally without their parents or guardians, they must be returned to their parents if the parents can be found, or they become wards of the state.

Finally, there is the issue of the Integrity of the nation.  Simply put, we shouldn’t allow anyone into the US who doesn’t like us.  There should be several simple requirements for all illegal immigrants who otherwise qualify (see above) to stay: a strong and visible desire to become US citizens, an effort to learn English, a willingness to surrender any loyalties to any other nation.  This one is an issue: there are any number of countries with which the US currently allows US citizens to have dual citizenship.  There are also legal grounds for dual citizenship.  For example, a child of US citizens born overseas (while serving in the military for example) may well be a citizen of that country while also being a US citizen.  As a matter of policy US citizens should be required to surrender citizenship of another country when they reach their majority.  New adult citizens should likewise have to surrender their previous citizenship upon acceptance of US citizenship. Simply put, you are no longer an “Irishman,” or an “Irish-American,” you are an American.

Is all this fair to those who have applied for citizenship and followed the rules?  I would submit that the key is this: find a penalty that seems fair and use it.  If you are hard-working, want to be here, aren’t breaking the law, and are willing to commit to being an American – I want you here.  If you broke the law in getting here, but haven’t otherwise broken the law, then the simple answer is: pay the penalty and let’s get you the test and let’s make you a citizen.  If the above doesn’t pertain: if you aren’t hard-working, if you don’t want to be here but simply want to exploit the system, if you have been breaking the law, if you don’t really, really want to be an American – I don’t want you here.  Out you go.

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Marriage

There has been a good deal of discussion about gay marriage in the news over the last few weeks, but two things seem to have omitted from the conversation.  The first is: a serious discussion on what is a marriage?  And the second, following from the first, is: given what marriage is, who, that is, which governmental body, decides who can and who cannot engage in such an act?

As one might suspect, there has been a good deal of posturing and opining by figures on all sides of the argument about marriage and, in particular, the rights of people to marry.  This misses the mark.  In fact, the question of marriage can be reduced to this: is marriage a right or is marriage a legal agreement – specifically, a contract?  If it is a right, that would suggest that marriage exists apart from government, that it is provided to us by God, or if you prefer, by nature.  But, it difficult to argue that it is a right when we consider that a marriage, under any circumstances, requires a whole host of things to be valid: both parties need to be adults, both parties need to be competent (the insane can’t get married), both parties have to be unencumbered – that is, free to enter into the marriage, and in some jurisdictions both parties have to be free of certain diseases. 

There is little reason to believe that anyone would suggest that any activity so circumscribed could be labeled a ‘right.’  The Bible, on the other hand, strongly suggests that marriage is a contract – the word covenant is used repeatedly in reference to marriage, and while in those cases a covenant is an agreement, a contract, between man and God, it is nonetheless a contract.  But the media insists that denying the gay community the “right to marry” is a violation of their civil rights.  Simply put, if marriage is a right, then government has only a very narrow ability to control my marrying.  But, of course, governments – all governments – have throughout history exercised a wide range of controls on marriage.  Further, it is difficult to imagine a ‘right’ that requires both the exercising of the right and the consent of two people.

It would seem, in fact, that to define marriage of any type as a ‘right’ is simply false.  But, it would be necessary to do so – define marriage as a right rather than a contract – if you wish to label denial of marriage to the gay community as a violation of civil rights.

On the other hand, if marriage is a contract, not a right, we need ask who has jurisdiction in the law?  Strictly speaking, commercial contracts and marriage contracts are not the same thing, but it may help in clarifying the problem if we begin with commercial contracts.

In the United States there is a federal code that addresses the bulk of all contracts: the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC).  It was drafted to bring commonality to the commercial codes across the various states and territories of the US.  Each state is free to adopt sections of the UCC, as well as to amend elements of it as they see fit.  This is what state legislatures do: they write and amend law. 

It is true that the marriage contract has always – for 6000 years – been viewed in a different manner than any other contract.  But it is a contract, just a unique form of a contract.  Thus, there are the various restrictions on valid marriages listed above (which is by no means a definitive and all-inclusive list).  Using similar procedures and concepts as with commercial contracts, states have drafted those laws that have defined who can enter into marriage and under what circumstances.

The basis for US contract law (at the Federal and state level), as with entire UCC (and much of the rest of US law) is English Common Law.  But legislatures have gone well beyond English Common Law and continue to define and refine the law in accordance with events of the day and the desires of the electorate.  And so, we have more than 50 different jurisdictions in the US (the 50 states plus Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, Washington, DC, etc.) and each one has the opportunity to define various contractual relationships as they see fit.  Marriage is one of them.  It is worth noting, of course, that more than 30 states have passed legislation that defines marriage strictly in terms of it being ‘between a man and a woman.’  Among these is, of course, California, where 58% of the electorate voted for such a definition only to have several judges overturn their vote.  (That the President seemed and seems unconcerned by such an act, even though he recently professed some angst over the idea of the Supreme Court overturning an act by Congress is confusing, but doesn’t seem to trouble him.)  That the voters continue to vote in support of the traditional definition of marriage, while the President and the main-stream media (and their polling cohorts) continue to insist that the nation supports a different definition of marriage is to be accepted as one of the realities of politics.  But it is politics.

What is significant is that this is the appropriate action.  If the citizenry are concerned about a particular facet of the law, it is perfectly within their powers - as the source of all power in government derives from the people – to hold a referendum to define that facet as they see fit.  31 States have now done so.  What is not appropriate is that judges, in the face of a clear mandate from the general populace in the form of a referendum, seek to define something as a right which is clearly a contract.

The significance of the voters’ decisions is that democracy has produced a result that does not fit with the story of the President or the media.  The President can lobby for change, and the media can follow his lead.  But what the voters should insist, and this is arguably more important than any argument about the definitions of marriage, is that the President respect the vote of the people – the real government – and not seek to undermine it by calling for judicial activism when it suits his political agenda.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

The 100-Yard Dash and End to Hyphenated Americanism

Race?  You Mean Like the Preakness?

We were informed today of something that I have had a hard time getting my head around for, well, since someone at the Census Bureau first announced this would happen, maybe 40 years ago; namely the current birth rate for minorities now constitutes more than 50% of births.  So, the minority is the majority?  I don’t really know how that works.  So, I read on. 

Just a little further in the article I read that ‘non-Hispanic whites’ will be outnumbered in the US by the year 2042.  That makes me ask the question: what is an ‘Hispanic white?’  That would seem to be obvious, but it isn’t to me, and here’s why: just a month or so ago we were all introduced to a Mr. Zimmerman down in Florida, who is, we were told, a ‘white-Hispanic.’  In as much as there needs to be a distinction ‘white Hispanic,’ there must also be a distinction ‘non-white Hispanic,’ (not to be confused with a ‘non-Hispanic white’).

Well, if you ask me, someone with the name ‘Zimmerman’ (good, solid ‘Hispanic’ name there…  Huh?) who must then be further described as ‘white Hispanic’ so that we ‘know’ what he is (and what exactly is he?) has pretty much reached my definition of a product of the ‘melting pot.’

But that hardly fits the story line someone is trying to sell.  Someone wants to stir up the pot.  What is the point of putting a headline “RACIAL TIPPING POINT” on the front page?  Is this a plea for some group in society to start procreating at a higher rate?  Is it a call for forced sterilization of another group?  What possible sane reason exists to even track this weird information?  Particularly given the inane reality that they force themselves to identify a man named Zimmerman as a ‘white Hispanic.’  Why not call him a ‘tanned German?’

Is this of any value whatsoever?  Well, sure.  It stirs up people to perhaps buy more newspapers and news magazines, listen to another insipid news talk show populated by folks who have nothing better to do then reproach the average taxpayer, and it creates more room for discussion and regulatory action by bureaucrats and policy wonks.

See, there is the problem.  You want to know who is keeping racism alive in the US, who really works at it on a daily basis?  Two key groups: the Federal Bureaucracy (start with the Census Bureau, and then make your way to Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Department of Education – they are all awash with figures on every possible weird brake-down of society by races and castes and shoe size and bowling scores, and when you are done with them, take a hard look at the mainstream media.

Meanwhile, I sat and asked myself this morning if I knew anyone of one race.  I also asked my self if I can define anyone as a pure color.  I did have a good friend in college who was black, his name was Azubekay and he was from Nigeria – med student, great guy, skin the color Indian ink.  Everyone else I know I would say is some tone of khaki – some are dark khaki, some are light, some very light.  So what?  What does that prove?  Everyone has some goofy mix of ancestors; me, I’m descended from Irish, Portuguese, some French and Canadian (or so I was told as a kid – never really researched it).  So what am I?  Well, I’ll tell you, I’m an American.  I’m not Irish-American, I’m not Portuguese-American, I’m not anything else, just an American.  You want to know what race I am?  I’ll stick with human.

Think about this: if the press had reported only that ‘Treyvon Martin was shot by Mr. Zimmerman,’ would we perhaps view that incident with a slightly different perspective?  Who benefited from reporting the tragedy in this manner?  (What is certain is that the nation as a whole did not.)

As for the Census Bureau, maybe they should focus on something else.  Maybe just focus on getting the basic count right. 

As for me, I really don’t care where you came from, who your great grandparents were, or how much melanin is in your skin.  (We all have melanin; in fact, with very few exceptions (spiders), all creatures have some melanin in them.)  Ancestry, besides being a fun topic of conversation at a cocktail party (“I’m the 9th cousin of Jesse James” (I’m not, but it would make for a few minutes of interesting conversation)) and for the sake of certain specific medical conditions, tells me nothing about you.  You are who you are, irrespective of who they were.  You parents might be criminals, and you might be a great doctor or jurist or inventor.  Alternatively, your grandparents might have been geniuses and philanthropists and you are a slothful delinquent.  Does it matter if they were born in Gabon, Gambia, Georgia, Germany, Ghana, Greece, Grenada, Guatemala, Guinea Bissau or Guyana?  How?  How does it matter?  And your skin color?  Maybe we should test for it so we can determine if someone is a ‘white Hispanic’ or a ‘non-white Hispanic,’ or a test to measure melanin content.  What could that possibly prove?  What benefit to society would that provide?  I hope that sounds as insane to you as it does to me.

More than 100 years ago President Roosevelt (T.R.) called for an end to ‘hyphenated Americans.’  He called for people to stop viewing themselves as ‘Irish-American, Dutch- American, German-American and simply view themselves as ‘Americans.’’  His call is more important today then it ever was.  The wonks and clowns in Washington, and in the media, may not understand that, but it is up to us to stress it.  The next time someone asks you your race, choose ‘other’ and write in ‘American.’  If you have a chance to talk to someone, do your best to make them very uncomfortable for asking what is truly a racist question – let’s stop this foolishness right now.  It is certain that neither the government nor the media want to stop it; so it’s time we just took care of it ourselves.

(It is perhaps worth noting that if you reach back 40 generations you have more than 1 billion ancestors – more than the total population of the world 8 centuries ago – which means that, mathematically speaking, we are all 40th cousins or less.)

Saturday, May 5, 2012

Mariano Rivera - Excellence Personified

I'll begin by saying that I’m a life-long Red Sox fan, and therefore am genetically disposed to hate the Yankees.  That being said, what happened Thursday night is terrible: Rivera, out shagging flies before the start of the game, ran into the wall and tore his ACL, certainly ending his playing for the year and possibly ending his career.

For anyone who loves baseball, or sports in general, or is just a ‘student of the human condition,’ this is a sad thing, sad because Rivera is, in his chosen profession, what we should all strive to be: someone who loves what he does and does it as well as he possibly can.  That Rivera also does it as well as anyone else has ever done it is (or was) for all of us to enjoy.  Even as a Red Sox fan, who has more than once seen Rivera ‘nail the coffin shut’ on the Red Sox, watching Rivera come in and get 3 outs was watching a true master at his craft.

Whether it is sports, watching Messi nonchalantly tap in the ball with his heel, or Brady lead the Pats down the field for a score with just a minute left in the game, that kind of artistry is every bit as magical as listening to Yo Yo Ma or Itzhak Perlman (a devout Mets fan), and thus his loss for the rest of the year and perhaps permanently is a sad thing.

I have written elsewhere about the loss of Junior Seau, and obviously the death of Junior Seau is a much greater loss then a torn knee.  But Mariano Rivera and Junior Seau shared this: they were true masters at their craft, they not only played with brilliance, they loved what they did and in that lay the roots of their excellence: they loved what they did and worked as hard at mastering their craft as anyone else in their respective game (or art).  They are examples to us all in anything we do.

Here’s hoping Mariano returns to play next year, even if it is bad news for the Red Sox.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

Victory In Afghanistan?

The list of ‘old saws’ about Afghanistan is long and storied (my favorite being ‘Graveyard of Empires.’)  They are of course, like many clichés, a little bit of truth but also a good deal of nonsense.  As with most clichés and pithy comments about war, they sound good, but after some simple investigation they are often found wanting.

Afghanistan has a long history of having been conquered, but, as the pundits will quickly point out, it ‘is never really conquered,’ and sooner or later ‘throws’ off its conquerors to emerge once again, unconquered, wild and free (fill in your own modifiers).  The problem with this kind of thing is that it can be said for virtually any country on earth that has been conquered, unless one thing happens – which I’ll get to shortly.  The great Prussian theorist on war (Clausewitz) had it right: in war, nothing is permanent.

Thus, we beat the snot out of Japan – but they re-emerged.  Germany was pummeled and pounded until the rubble bounced; it is now the powerhouse of Europe.  Over the last 3000 years Italy has been conquered so many times we have all lost track – still there.  How about Belgium and the Netherlands?  Virtually ground into dust twice just in the last century, but back with a vengeance.

When it comes to unlimited wars – wars in which the leadership of one country eliminates the leadership of another country – there are only a few possible ‘successful’ results:

1)                     Remove the leadership, establish a new government, and then leave.  The period following the establishment of the new government can be short or long, but once you leave, you give the country back to its original inhabitants.  We just did this in Iraq.
2)                     Remove the leadership, destroy the country, turn it into a wasteland, and depart.  If someone wants to move in, fine.  Tried by the Mongols quite successfully in several places in central Asia, and by others throughout history.  Again, once the conquering army departs the surviving locals will move back in.
3)                     Remove the leadership and then colonize the country.  This will be successful only if you bring in LOTS of colonists – the one exception I mentioned above. Of course, if you don’t bring lots of colonists you will be buried by population inequalities.  No matter when you look in history, the issue of level of effort in colonization is the key to long-term success.  For example, Persia conquered much of modern Turkey in the 5 century BC, but there was no large-scale colonization.  When the Greeks under Alexander swept out the Persians, they were gone.  And the Medes and the descendants of the Hittites returned to local power.  The British ruled India for more than 100 years, and established a British style government and culture on top of the Hindu and Mogul influences.  But the British eventually left and the Hindu culture and the Indian people have returned.  Conversely, the European conquest of both North and South America was so dominant not because of any determination to ‘wipe out’ the American Indians or Aztecs or Incas, but because millions of Europeans colonized the two continents.  The French tried to colonize Vietnam, but the numbers were against them.
4)                     Remove the leadership, but don’t eliminate them; later share power with them.  Not really unlimited warfare, it ends the war before the leadership has really been destroyed.  Once the old leadership returns to power they will re-establish themselves and their old country – as soon as the would-be conquerors are gone.  This is what the US appears to be ready to do in Afghanistan.

The point here is that every country can be ‘conquered’ if the would-be conquerors are both able and willing to commit the necessary resources.  But in the long term, which in the eyes of reporters without some historical context, is supposed to mean ‘for ever,’ ‘conquering’ (in that context) only really occurs when a nation is destroyed and its people displaced.  In this regard Afghanistan is no different then any other nation.  Its one distinction is that fewer people have really cared about the area for any extended period of time.  Genghis Khan and his sons controlled the area until their dynasty unraveled; the Moguls controlled the area for several centuries; the British paid dearly for the area, but eventually controlled it as much as they needed and wanted to.  Only to the extent that the Mogul emperors moved people in to occupy, live in, colonize and rule Afghanistan did the Moguls extend their rule in time further then the others.

But Afghanistan is no different then Fiji in this one thing: if no one colonizes it, it will revert to its origins.  So, if you want to look at it that way, you could label Fiji with all the same adjectives and adverbs that get stacked up in any wonk’s discourse on Afghanistan.  And it would be as meaningful.  (This should also be noted when the conversation of “American Empire” comes up; the term invariably is associated with the British, French, German (and a few others) efforts to grab land and establish colonies in Africa, Asia and the Americas.  The US has never attempted to establish colonies and the difference is critical.)

All this is important as we look at what our government is now trying to do in Afghanistan and whether it can succeed.  In 2001 we removed Mullah Omar and the Taliban, and their symbiotic/parasitic allies al Qaeda, from rule.  But the Taliban, and Mullah Omar, remains alive and viable.  We have now made it clear that we will negotiate with them, and though we have hedged our bets a bit on the negotiations, the Taliban have recognized that we are not trying to eliminate them.  The opportunity for their return is therefore very much alive, and if we were to place a bet on it, probably better then even odds.

As far as the US being there for another 10 or 15 years – it will be trying for the soldiers sent to Afghanistan during that decade, and their families.  But, from the perspective of a nation making an investment in its own security, which is ostensibly what the US is doing, that is more or less a minor investment.

But whether we stay for 15 years or 50 (as we did in Germany), the following will still be true: the same people live there, and the same political movement – the Taliban – will still exist, unless the people of Afghanistan eliminate it.  They – the Taliban - will certainly be willing to negotiate a power-sharing arrangement with Karzai and the government in Kabul, recognizing that once they are back in power, even if only partially, they will then have a free hand in regaining control.  And, it is worth noting that Mullah Omar, leader of the Taliban, is 53 years old.  In 2024 he will be 65, certainly young enough to rule.

As for how, or whether, the US intends to continue to influence the power struggle in the region, between India on one hand and Pakistan and China on the other, it remains to be seen.  Is the US departing Afghanistan with an implicit understanding that Pakistan will do a better job of keeping Afghanistan under control in the next several decades then it did in the 1990s?  Is the US confident that political culture in Pakistan has advanced to the point that the country is stable enough to move forward, nuclear weapons and all, without the continued implied pressure from the close presences of US forces?  Is the US confident that the Chinese presence in Pakistan, which has been growing steadily over the past 10 – 15 years, will not be used to upset the political equilibrium and leave India convinced of a need to act in its own interests?  Are we comfortable with the developing strategic conundrum of three nations – India, Pakistan and Iran – that are (or will soon be in the case of Iran) nuclear powers, with each sharing an uneasy to sometimes-hostile relationship with the other two?  These and a host of other questions may or may not have been considered as the current administration hastened to sign a deal and enunciate a way forward in Afghanistan and South Asia.  But all of these issues will remain for years to come, long after the agreement penned in Kabul a few days ago is long forgotten.

Monday, April 30, 2012

Crucify Them? What do to about Petty Dictators

We have all seen the mid-level EPA administrator in the video talking about his philosophy of enforcement, which might be summed up as: “We make a few examples and everyone else stays in line.”  And I’m glad that he is no longer in his post, though he should have been fired, not allowed to resign.

The problem is not simply with Mr. Armendariz; it is not simply that he is not a satrap for some absolute monarch, free to interpret the law as he pleases.  (It was clear that he wanted the law to work that way, that is exactly what he said – more than a year ago.  And we must assume that he pursued that policy as much as he was able until this public airing of the video forced him to recant.

What he demonstrated, and the reason why he should have been fired, was that he demonstrated precisely how a nation of laws does NOT work.  Further, I suspect that his actions were an indication of more than the extent to which the Obama administration hates the oil and gas industry.  That hate is relatively insignificant when placed against a much larger issue: the issue of the corruption and abuse of power.

Now the abuse of power is not new; it has been going on for 6,000 years at least.  But it seems as if it has been increasing over the last several years (in the US and world-wide).  While we can debate what it is about power that is so corrosive of morals and behavior, the simple fact is that it is intolerable in a democracy, in any nation that believes that bureaucrats and elected officials are the servants of the people, and that they must be held to strict accountability at all times.

Mr. Armendariz’s video demonstrated at a minimum a flippancy to the rule of law.  It is probably more accurate to say that he believes, as do many in government, certainly many that worked for him, with him, and presumably those he worked for (who did not correct his behavior, but whose hands were forced only when – more than a year after that video, a member of Congress made it public) that the law is what they say it is.  It is all well and good for people to assert that ‘he was just saying this for effect,’ and that ‘he apologized.’  But the fact is that the abuse of power is part of the process of usurpation of power by those in government.  And it must never be tolerated to any degree if we wish to keep our freedoms.

While elected officials are at least subject to recall by irate voters, the bureaucrats who work in the vast regulatory agencies of the federal government are not.  In fact, with the exception of the most senior officers in those various agencies, getting one removed for anything other than clearly illegal activity is difficult at best.  Yet these same regulators have, over time, come to assume the de facto power of Congress.  Legislation is passed creating an office and giving it general powers.  (Sometimes, there isn’t even legislation, simply a decision by the President, as President Nixon did in establishing the Environmental Protection Agency by executive order.)  Once the office is created the bureaucrats expand on these general orders with the crafting of regulations.  The only boundaries on those regulations are the imagination of the regulators, and the willingness of someone to sue them when the regulations become truly onerous.  There is no process of review unless people – citizens – object.  And then you have a citizen or business fighting against an entrenched bureaucracy with all the power of the federal government behind them.

This lack of any serious review of the expansion of powers has stripped the citizenry of real powers and transferred it into the hands of bureaucrats like the would-be petty dictators at EPA.  At a minimum there should be a thorough investigation of the EPA, as well as the dismissal of Mr. Armendariz’s immediate superior.  The nominal Inspector General’s office in the EPA should also be reviewed.  Then Congress must take up the debate of just how much latitude an agency had to draft regulations and what procedures might be implemented to force some sort of real, rather than cursory, oversight of these bureaucrats and petty dictators.